We Compared Native and Display Ad CTR in Newsletters. The Average Called It a Tie. The Median Gave Native 2×

Native vs display ad CTR in newsletters: pooled, it’s a tie at 0.40% vs 0.42%. At the typical publisher, native earns 2× display. Here’s why.

Table of Contents

Table of Content

Share this article

Share this article

What is the CTR of native vs display ads in newsletters? We analyzed our own platform data to find out, and the answer depends on how you count. Pooled across every publisher in our sample, native ads clicked at 0.40% and display ads at 0.42%, close enough to call a tie. Look at the typical publisher instead, and native ads earn 0.17% against display’s 0.09%, roughly double. Both figures come from the same paid, verified impressions and clicks over our most recent 30 days, calculated honestly both times. The distance between them is the most useful lesson in email ad benchmarking: an average tells you who is biggest, while a median tells you what is normal.

Quick answer: Across all newsletter publishers on Passendo's platform, native and display ads have almost the same pooled click-through rate: 0.40% vs 0.42%. At the typical publisher, native ads earn about twice the CTR of display: 0.17% vs 0.09%. The pooled display figure is pulled up by one large publisher with unusually strong display results, so the median is the better benchmark for a single newsletter.

Pooled Across Our Platform, Native and Display Newsletter Ads Perform Almost Identically

During a recent 30-day period, native ads in newsletters on our platform earned a 0.40% click-through rate. Display ads earned 0.42%. Read on its own, that looks like a clear result: both formats work equally well.

This figure is a pooled average. We added up all the clicks from every publisher, added up all the impressions, and divided one by the other. That means big publishers count for more than small ones. A publisher that serves a lot of ads shapes the result far more than one that serves only a few.

So the pooled average shows what happened across the whole platform. A publisher who wants to know what to expect from their own newsletter needs a different view, with each publisher looked at separately. 

That view tells a very different story about native and display.

For the Typical Publisher, Native Ads Earn Roughly Double the CTR of Display

To find the typical publisher, we lined up every publisher in our sample by click-through rate and took the one in the middle. That median ignores size entirely: a small specialist newsletter and a large daily digest each count once. To be included, a publisher needed at least 10,000 impressions in a format, so a few stray views can’t swing the result.

Measured that way, native ads earned a 0.17% CTR over our most recent 30 days, while display ads earned 0.09%. That works out to about 17 clicks per 10,000 native ad views against 9 for display. At the typical newsletter publisher, native ads earn roughly twice the clicks of display ads.

Passendo platform sample · paid, verified impressions and clicks · most recent 30 days
Passendo platform sample · paid, verified impressions and clicks · most recent 30 days

A single middle value can be a fluke, so we checked the rest of the line-up. At the lower quartile, the point a quarter of the way up, native ads earned about 10 clicks per 10,000 views and display about 4. At the upper quartile, native reached roughly 52 and display about 15.

Passendo platform sample · publishers with ≥10,000 impressions in a format · most recent 30 days
Passendo platform sample · publishers with ≥10,000 impressions in a format · most recent 30 days

The platform, the time window and the verified clicks are all identical, yet the headline has changed completely. Counted publisher by publisher, native outperforms display at every point we measured. That raises the obvious question of how one dataset can give both answers.

How a Single Large Publisher Can Flip an Email Ad Benchmark

The two results diverge because of a single publisher, which accounts for the majority of all ad clicks in our sample. Its readers also click display ads at rates most newsletters only see on native.

Together, those two facts leave the pooled average with little choice. That publisher contributes most of the clicks, so its strong display performance pulls the platform-wide display CTR up to 0.42%, level with native. Display looks excellent on average because one very large publisher is excellent at it.

Picture a room where the average net worth soars the moment a billionaire walks in. Nobody else got richer; the arithmetic simply started reporting on one guest. A traffic-weighted ad benchmark behaves the same way. The more volume a publisher serves, the more the result describes that publisher rather than the market.

One publisher accounts for the majority of clicks in our sample. That is enough to turn a 2× gap into a tie.

In the median, that same publisher counts just once, like every other newsletter in the sample. Its banner-friendly readers become one data point among many, and what remains is the pattern most publishers actually see: native comfortably ahead.

The pooled average and the median are both accurate because they answer different questions: one describes total traffic across the platform, the other what a typical newsletter can expect. Problems begin when the first is presented as the second, which is how most single-number benchmarks reach the market.

Why Native Ads Out-Click Display in Most Newsletters

A newsletter is something people choose to read, and native ads take advantage of that. The defining trait of native ads compared with display ads is that a native ad borrows the publication’s own typography, layout and tone. In a newsletter, that puts the ad in the same reading flow as the editorial around it. Readers treat it like the next item in the email: they read the headline, judge whether it’s useful, and click if it is.

Display ads ask for a different kind of attention. A banner announces itself as advertising before anyone has read a word. Readers who have spent years scrolling past banners on the web bring that reflex into the inbox. The ad still gets seen, but it has to work harder to get read.

That explains why native leads at the typical publisher, and it also explains the exception in our data. Some audiences click display ads freely, and a publisher with that kind of readership can do very well with banners. For most publishers, the median is the realistic benchmark, and the median points to native first.

Data snapshot

  • 0.40% vs 0.42%: native vs display CTR, pooled across all publishers
  • 0.17% vs 0.09%: native vs display CTR at the typical (median) publisher
  • ~3×: CTR of top slots compared with bottom slots at the typical publisher
  • ~1.1%: CTR of native ads in top positions at the typical publisher, the strongest inventory we measured
  • More than half: share of raw click events rejected before billing in a typical week

Four Questions to Ask Before Trusting Any Email Ad CTR Benchmark

Newsletter audiences vary enormously, so a single benchmark number carries a lot of hidden assumptions. Four questions bring them into view.

Weighted by what? A pooled average weights publishers by volume, while a median weights them equally. When a benchmark doesn’t say which, it’s most likely pooled, and its biggest contributors are steering it.

Across how many publishers? A figure drawn from three newsletters and one drawn from thirty look equally authoritative on a slide. The sample size tells you how far the number can travel.

Is one outlier moving the number? In our native vs display data, one publisher with unusual behavior turned a 2× gap into a tie. Ask whether the result survives without the largest contributor, or ask for the median alongside the average.

What counts as a click? Raw click events include security scanners, bots and duplicates. On our platform, more than half of raw click events in a typical week are rejected before they reach an invoice. A benchmark built on unfiltered clicks may be measuring firewalls as much as readers.

A benchmark that answers all four is one you can plan around. One that answers none is decoration.

Ad Position Still Matters More Than Ad Format

Format is a real lever, and position is a bigger one. At the typical publisher on our platform, native ads earn about twice the CTR of display. Ads at the top of a newsletter earn about three times the CTR of ads at the bottom. Pooled across the platform, that gap widens to 5.6×, as our analysis of newsletter ad placement showed.

table-format-vs-position

The two levers also stack in a predictable order. A display ad in the top slot still comfortably out-clicks a native ad near the footer. Native ads in top positions are the strongest inventory we measured, at about 1.1% CTR for the typical publisher and 1.4% pooled.

For publishers, the practical order is simple: choose the slot first, then choose the format that suits it. Native wins the format question for most newsletters, and it performs best in a slot readers actually reach.

Key takeaways

  • Pooled across all publishers, native and display newsletter ads have almost the same CTR: 0.40% vs 0.42%.
  • At the typical publisher, native ads earn about twice the CTR of display: 0.17% vs 0.09%.
  • Native leads at the lower quartile, the median and the upper quartile alike.
  • The pooled tie comes from one large publisher whose readers click display ads unusually often.
  • For a single newsletter, the median is the more realistic benchmark.
  • Position moves CTR more than format: top slots earn about 3× the CTR of bottom slots at the typical publisher.

Measure Native and Display Performance by Slot With Verified Data

Every number in this analysis comes from the same place your own benchmarks should: verified clicks, broken down by format and by slot, for each publisher individually. Passendo is an email ad server that gives publishers that view of their own inventory. It serves native and display ads inside newsletters, filters invalid traffic before anything is billed, and reports performance for every placement. You see which format works in which slot for your audience, instead of relying on someone else’s average.

Methodology: internal analysis of a sample of paid, verified (fraud-filtered) newsletter ad impressions and clicks across active publishers on the Passendo platform, publishers anonymized. Native and display figures cover the most recent 30 days; median and quartile figures include publishers with at least 10,000 impressions in a format.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average CTR of native vs display ads in newsletters?

On Passendo’s platform, native and display newsletter ads perform almost identically when all traffic is pooled: 0.40% CTR for native and 0.42% for display over the most recent 30 days. At the typical publisher, measured by the median, native ads earn 0.17% against 0.09% for display, roughly twice the click-through rate.

A pooled average weights each publisher by its traffic volume. In Passendo’s sample, a single publisher accounts for the majority of ad clicks and has unusually strong display performance, which pulls the pooled display CTR level with native. The median counts every publisher once, so it shows the pattern most publishers experience: native ahead by about 2×.

For most newsletter publishers, native ads are the stronger starting point, earning roughly double the CTR of display at the typical publisher. Display can perform very well with audiences that already click banners. In either case, ad position has a larger effect than format, so the best slot matters more than the choice between native and display.

The median is the better guide for what a single newsletter should expect, because every publisher counts equally. The pooled average describes total traffic across all publishers and can be dominated by the largest one. A trustworthy benchmark reports both, along with the number of publishers behind it.

A verified click is a click on an email ad that has passed fraud filtering, meaning it came from a real person rather than a bot, a corporate security scanner, an AI crawler or a duplicate event. Verified clicks are what advertisers are billed for. On Passendo’s platform, more than half of raw click events in a typical week are rejected before billing.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Keep up-to-date with our latest blog posts, featuring the newest industry trends and updates.

Suggested articles

Passendo does what AdButler does in email, plus native ads, programmatic demand and email traffic filtering. Compare formats, demand and pricing.
Agentic advertising is reaching email. Five steps to get newsletter inventory ready for AI buying agents: labels, products, pricing, rules and measurement.
Build the newsletter, keep your stack. Feedotter’s founder on modernizing newsletter production, ad ops, and what AI changes for publishers.